The uproar over President Amit Chakma receiving a remuneration of nearly $1 million as president during 2014 represented a natural reaction.
President Chakma did not commit any fraud or crime. Although it was legally negotiated, it was unusual – but not unheard of – in academic settings, nationally and internationally. Usually, people take the leave and are paid during that period. Not taking leave and then collecting both regular and leave salary is questionable. Yes, it points to a flaw in judgment on the part of the negotiating committee representing the Board.
With his extensive experience in leadership positions in a number of Canadian Universities, President Chakma should have known better.
As it stands, the expectation of this uproar varies. Everyone has one, two or more views. Most do not support the practice. The way forward is also diverse.
On one hand is the contention he signed a legal contract and is entitled to it. On the other hand is the view he lacks judgment and that disqualifies him as president. In fact, two groups – the University of Western Ontario Faculty Association (UWOFA) and University of Western Ontario Staff Association (UWOSA) – formally approved this latter view. Also, the Senate was given a notice for a special meeting to discuss the issue. Following spirited speeches this special meeting rejected the motion of non-confidence against Dr Chakma by 30 to 49.
Now, what did President Chakma do after the disclosure? First, he promised to return the study leave money received during 2014 with no conditions attached. Also, he forgoes similar commitment for 2019. Under most circumstances, this will be the end of the story.
However, from the people at the very top in academia, much more is expected.
As a follow up, President Chakma offered an unconditional apology to all concerned (“Difficult to express how truly sorry I am,” Western News, April 9).
Also, he has personally and equivocally apologized to the academic community for this “mistake” through his personal statement to the Senate dated April 10.
As I see it, any success must begin with forgiveness.
This is not about President Chakma or any single group or individual. I am pleased Senate voted against the non-confidence in the president and Board chair. Most of us have experienced ups and downs at Western – that is natural in most large institutions with complex governance. No single person or group holds the key to the success.
We must direct our focus on the education of our students. We have completed the soul searching. The time has come for all of us to push in the same direction. I am confident we will do just that. The alternative is that we waste our energy, divided.
Shiva M. Singh
Distinguished University Professor
Department of Biology