* * *
Millions of people confine themselves to their homes as they battle an invisible, viral enemy. Schools and theatres close. Playgrounds empty. Medical staff choose which patients will get life-saving respirators, and which will not. That was polio at its North American peak in the early 1950s. Today, the worldwide COVID-19 outbreak is both familiar and concerning to Western medical historian Shelley McKellar. She sees parallels in the current pandemic with the trajectory of history’s other fast-moving diseases, including the Black Death of the 1300s; the cholera outbreak of the 18th century; the 1918 Spanish flu epidemic; polio’s apex in the 1950s; and modern-day viruses such as HIV, SARS, MERS, H1N1 and Zika. She cites a resiliency on two levels: On one level, the resiliency of people – we are still here and still moving forward. On the other, there’s the resiliency of the disease – we haven’t seen the end of this. Students in her Plague, Pox and Flu: Disease in Global History undergraduate course are in the rare position of learning the historical lessons of pandemics while living in one. “It’s a great year to teach this course,” said McKellar, the Jason A. Hannah Chair in the History of Medicine at the Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry. “I’m so proud of my students as they’re identifying recurring themes (from history) that they see through these news stories.” Although theories of contagion have evolved considerably over time, approaches to slowing the spread of disease hasn’t changed much. “We’ve seen similar strategies in how to address it. This is all about containment, all about barriers, all about strategic quarantine.” Even the origin of the word quarantine stems from Italy in the 1300s, when sailors arriving on ships in Venice had to remain on board for 40 (“quaranta” ) days to as a defence against spreading the plague. The Black Death of 1347-51, remains the most devastating pandemic in history, having killed as many as 200 million people, including half of what was then Europe’s population. “Its incidence and mortality were so egregious,” McKellar said. It upended the labour system, changed social and economic structures, and recovery from its wide-reaching impact took as long as six generations. Could this outbreak have such far-reaching effect? McKellar stresses her job is to examine the past – not predict the future. In history, she tells her students, “time and place matter. The disease process is geographically contingent and culturally contingent.” But some themes of past outbreaks do find echoes in the present pandemic, she said. One is the blame game used to further political agendas, rather than advance medical ends – a tendency that extends even to disease nomenclature. In the 15th century, for example, Italians and Germans referred to syphilis as the ‘French disease,’ the French called it the ‘Italian disease,’ while the Dutch blamed the Spanish, and the Russians pinned it on the Poles.
Students in Western medical historian Shelley McKellar’s ‘Plague, Pox and Flu: Disease in Global History’ undergraduate course are in the rare position of learning the historical lessons of pandemics while living in one.






